[She had already gathered that they remembered some things differently, that there was somehow some discrepancy between their experiences she could not quite explain, but she had not imagined it to quite this extent.

Well. One thing at a time.]

Of course she is a 'she.' You are remembering things differently?

[She curls her fingers lightly, bringing her hand to rest against her chin.]

This is... very confusing. You are remembering the Professor as a 'he.' We are both thinking of Professor Eisner?